Warrior Protection
User avatar
Discord:

teebling#5444


Bnet:

Teeb#2674


Posts: 1132
Likes: 2124
Orc Warrior 525 posts
1 year ago (Pre-release)
1 year ago (Pre-release)
 •  Unread

This feature has been discontinued as of patch v1.2 due to feedback and technical issues.

You can now earn achievements by doing things that benefit the Barrens Chat community - whether that is writing a guide for Classic, recruiting new members or publicising the site on social media.

Here are the achievements:

Image • Create a WoW Classic guide for PvE stuff

Image • Create a WoW Classic guide for PvP stuff

Image • Create a WoW Classic guide for a Profession

Image • Reach maximum level (60)

Image • Recruit 3 new members through the refer a friend tool

Image • Link Barrens Chat on 3 separate social networks of your choosing

Image • Report a bug

Image • Report an inappropriate post

Image • For distinguished service to the community (awarded at my discretion)


If you have met the requirements of any of the achievements, PM me and I will award you accordingly. If you have any ideas for other types of achievements, I'd love to hear your suggestions!


Congrats to [mention]Syturio[/mention] for earning the first Trade Guide achievement and [mention]Firelord[/mention] for earning the first Distinguished Service achievement!

   slud Cletus
Undercity
User avatar
Bnet:

Syturio#2552


Posts: 182
Likes: 134
182 posts
Alliance
Alliance 182 posts
1 year ago (Pre-release)
1 year ago (Pre-release)
 •  Unread

I love this Achievements idea! Great work teebling.
But i think it has some majors flaws and people will probably abuse them in the long run.
Here is some feedback...



My concerns:

  • People will make low-quality / low-effort guides just for the sake of getting an easy ImageImageImage achievement.
  • People will make fake accounts to get Image achievement.
  • "If you have met the requirements of any of the achievements, PM me", This means people will spam inbox asking for you to reward them.
  • What if multiple people report the same bug / post, all get the ImageImage anchievement? Thats not "special", and also means more inbox spam from people asking for rewards.



My suggestions:

  • I think you shouldn't tell people that they have to PM you to get the rewards. If the guides are good, they will get a lot of views and ADMINS will eventually reward them accordingly.
  • ImageImageImage achievements should be given ONLY to high-quality / well-produced / in-depth guides.
  • Only accounts that go above level 10+ count towards "refer a friend tool", this way people will not create fake accounts just to get the achievement.
  • Make the ImageImage more special, only for members that activily report bugs / posts.

   teebling Rootdancer
ModeratorPrivate Message
Image
Warrior Fury
User avatar
Posts: 209
Likes: 92
208 posts
Horde
Horde 208 posts
1 year ago (Pre-release)
1 year ago (Pre-release)
 •  Unread

Oh snap. Thank you teebling for that kind of praise, I didn't think I deserved that kind of achivement given my way. I am honoured!

All in all, an achievement system sounds well fun, but I do share some concerns together with Syturio.

teebling wrote:
1 year ago
If you have met the requirements of any of the achievements, PM me and I will award you accordingly.
This is my main worry, however. This is going to become one fel of a job for you. When the website grow, more and more people will be sending messages your way, and you could find yourself overwhelmed.

Sadly, I do not have anything in mind how to actually imrpove this, other than "making it automatic" but that is far easier said than done. Unless you can tick a box when you create a new thread.

Image
Image
Image

-- or something in line of that, and when people make their threads, a "shared admin inbox" gets notified of it, and they can assess whether it's achievement worthy, or not. But this means you will have to build yourself a trustworthy admin team, eventually.

   Syturio
Teldrassil
User avatar
Posts: 62
Likes: 61
Horde Hunter 62 posts
1 year ago (Pre-release)
1 year ago (Pre-release)
 •  Unread

This is so neat. Like syturio though im not sure about the 'bug' and 'spam' ones - they aren't really much of an achievement?

   omniGG
Thunder Bluff
User avatar
Posts: 8
Likes: 5
8 posts
Alliance
Alliance 8 posts
1 year ago (Pre-release)
1 year ago (Pre-release)
 •  Unread

How about an achievement for reaching each level tier? 10,20,30 etc

Undercity
User avatar
Bnet:

Syturio#2552


Posts: 182
Likes: 134
182 posts
Alliance
Alliance 182 posts
1 year ago (Pre-release)
1 year ago (Pre-release)
 •  Unread

omniGG wrote:
1 year ago
How about an achievement for reaching each level tier? 10,20,30 etc
Thats a bit over-kill.
Specially the first tiers, they are easy to get, not really an "achievement".

ModeratorPrivate Message
Image
Hunter Marksman
User avatar
Guild:

Barrens Chat


Posts: 90
Likes: 52
90 posts
Dwarf
Hunter
Dwarf Hunter 90 posts
1 year ago (Pre-release)
1 year ago (Pre-release)
 •  Unread

I'm a huge fan of these achievements, although part of me worries people will try to abuse the system you've implemented here try to attain them via false methods (referring themselves three times, reporting posts they've created themselves). But I guess seeing as you're the one who dishes out these achievements, you'll be able to tell if they've been legitimately obtained?

Awaiting Classic WoW

Image
Warrior Protection
User avatar
Discord:

teebling#5444


Bnet:

Teeb#2674


Posts: 1132
Likes: 2124
Orc Warrior 525 posts
1 year ago (Pre-release)
1 year ago (Pre-release)
 •  Unread

Will be making some revisions to this in the next patch - I have taken all the feedback on board, thanks :smile:

   Syturio res