Griznak wrote: ↑
5 months ago
I will be needing on all BoP rares and epics too, I can disenchant and sell shards on AH, which progresses my character further than you guys' gear upgrade is able to.
What a total bad faith argument.
This has been explained thousands of times for nearly two decades, including in this very thread, but if you're still having trouble understanding I'll try once again to break it down for you:
All BoEs have equal value to all members of the group because you can either buy or sell the item for the same amount of money.
BoPs, obviously, do not have equal value. If you want a real world example, imagine if Hands of the Exalted were a rare BoE. They might be worth about 100 gold to players based on similar pre-raid BIS blues. You cannot disenchant them for 100 gold worth of value.
Your argument holds no weight, but go ahead and try to claim that you're more important than anyone else in your group and see how far that mentality gets you once you've been blacklisted by the server.
Additionally, the argument about the names of the buttons (Need/Greed) or the images they depict is completely irrelevant. They mean different things in different situations (Pugs, guild groups, BoEs, BoPs, etc). Not only would it be impossible for Blizzard to design a different loot system for several situations, it would be pointless and needlessly complicated.